-: 00:03

Hey everyone, welcome back for another Deep Dive with me. And me.

-: 00:06

Today we're going to be tackling something I think a lot of us

-: 00:11

can relate to, and that's loyalty programs.

-: 00:13

Ooh, yeah, those are interesting.

-: 00:17

Yeah, we're taking Token Wisdom's A Closer Look series by Kayam,

-: 00:21

and you know, let's be honest, sometimes a ten minute read is

-: 00:22

a little much.

-: 00:23

It can feel like a dissertation.

-: 00:26

Yeah, consider this your express elevator right to the top.

-: 00:28

I like that analogy.

-: 00:31

The view is amazing, the air is thin, but at least we brought snacks.

-: 00:34

Well, it's definitely a view worth seeing.

-: 00:36

Kayam really doesn't mess around.

-: 00:39

He like excavates the whole evolution of loyalty and like the

-: 00:40

data that drives it. Yeah.

-: 00:43

And he even gets into some potential futures that might leave

-: 00:46

you looking at that grocery store rewards card a little differently.

-: 00:47

Yeah, that's what I'm talking about.

-: 00:50

You know, I went in thinking, oh, loyalty programs, free coffee,

-: 00:51

I get it. Right.

-: 00:52

Seems pretty straightforward.

-: 00:56

But then I hit this part in the essays where Kayam's talking about

-: 01:01

how airline loyalty programs are actually worth more than the airlines themselves. Oh, yeah. Yes.

-: 01:03

That's a big one. Yeah.

-: 01:04

Talk about a plot twist. Right.

-: 01:07

It's almost like the points themselves have become more valuable

-: 01:11

than the actual product or service they're supposed to be, you

-: 01:13

know, rewarding you for. Yeah.

-: 01:14

It's pretty wild.

-: 01:17

And that's just the tip of the iceberg.

-: 01:19

You know, he calls it the loyalty revolution.

-: 01:22

And for good reason, the whole game has changed.

-: 01:24

Okay, so walk me through this. What's changed?

-: 01:25

I remember like those punch cards.

-: 01:29

You buy 10 coffees, you get one free. Oh, yeah. Yeah.

-: 01:30

Is it really that different now?

-: 01:31

It's night and day.

-: 01:35

Those old school programs were like throwing darts blindfolded.

-: 01:38

You know, maybe you hit a customer's preference. Maybe not. Right.

-: 01:42

But now it's all about data, hyper personalized data.

-: 01:45

They're not just tracking what you buy, but how you buy it, when

-: 01:48

you buy it, where you buy it, even what you almost bought but didn't.

-: 01:53

So basically, they're building like a digital voodoo doll of my shopping habits. Pretty much.

-: 01:54

That's kind of unsettling.

-: 01:57

But I have to admit, it's also pretty fascinating. It is.

-: 02:00

And it's not just about serving you up ads for things you might like.

-: 02:04

I mean, Kayan points out that Starbucks, for example, uses their

-: 02:09

app data to optimize everything from inventory to like store locations. Wow.

-: 02:13

He highlights this one case study where a Starbucks in Seattle

-: 02:17

shifted their pastry delivery schedule by just like two hours

-: 02:22

based solely on loyalty app data and reduced waste by 15 percent.

-: 02:23

Okay, that's impressive.

-: 02:29

So like my latte addiction is actually helping to save the planet, sort of.

-: 02:30

In around that way.

-: 02:32

But how is all this data even collected?

-: 02:35

Are we all just like willingly handing it over? Mostly, yes.

-: 02:36

I mean, think about it.

-: 02:37

You sign up for that free app.

-: 02:38

You link your credit card.

-: 02:41

You share your location data for those personalized offers.

-: 02:42

Boom, you're in the system.

-: 02:46

And I bet most people don't even read the fine print, myself included. Right.

-: 02:47

We click agree and hope for the best.

-: 02:51

But Kayan really makes you think about the trade off we're making,

-: 02:55

you know, convenience and personalization in exchange for a level

-: 02:58

of data access that would have been unthinkable just a few years ago. All right.

-: 02:59

So we're being tracked.

-: 03:04

Our data is being used to optimize everything from inventory to marketing campaigns.

-: 03:08

And companies are getting really good at predicting what we want

-: 03:10

before we even know it ourselves.

-: 03:13

I'm starting to see why Kayan calls this a revolution.

-: 03:18

But what does it actually mean for us, the everyday consumers?

-: 03:21

Is this a good thing, a bad thing or somewhere in between?

-: 03:22

I think that's what we need to figure out.

-: 03:23

Honestly, it's a bit of both.

-: 03:26

On the one hand, you get, you know, more personalized offers,

-: 03:29

maybe even discover things you wouldn't have known you wanted. Yeah.

-: 03:30

Fewer irrelevant ads.

-: 03:32

More like tailored recommendations. Exactly.

-: 03:35

It's like having a personal shopper who actually gets you. Right.

-: 03:38

But that personal shopper is also reading your diary, tracking

-: 03:40

your every move. Yeah.

-: 03:42

And maybe even sharing that information with other companies. Exactly.

-: 03:45

And that's where the ethical considerations come in.

-: 03:46

How much access is too much?

-: 03:51

You know, where's the line between helpful personalization and creepy intrusion?

-: 03:54

And Kayan doesn't shy away from those questions.

-: 03:56

He even brings up this whole concept of data dignity.

-: 03:58

Ooh, data dignity.

-: 04:00

Which I found really thought provoking. Yeah.

-: 04:02

OK, now you have to explain that one. Yeah.

-: 04:05

I'm picturing my data wearing a little graduation cap.

-: 04:07

It's not that far off, actually.

-: 04:10

The idea is that we as individuals should have more control over

-: 04:11

our own data.

-: 04:15

We should be able to decide who has access to it, how it's used,

-: 04:18

and even potentially profit from it ourselves.

-: 04:21

So like instead of just blindly handing over my data to Starbucks

-: 04:26

for a free birthday drink, I could be like selling it to the highest bidder. Yeah.

-: 04:27

I'm into that.

-: 04:29

It's a radical idea, but it's gaining traction.

-: 04:33

Kayan even mentioned some startups that are already experimenting

-: 04:38

with like blockchain-based loyalty programs where your points

-: 04:42

are essentially like cryptocurrency that you can trade or sell. Hold on. Blockchain.

-: 04:43

Isn't that like Bitcoin and all that?

-: 04:46

I thought we were talking about like coffee rewards and airline miles.

-: 04:46

It's all connected.

-: 04:47

Think about it.

-: 04:52

Blockchain is a decentralized, secure way to track and manage digital assets.

-: 04:55

So imagine a world where your loyalty points aren't just tied

-: 04:58

to one company but exist on a universal blockchain ledger.

-: 05:02

You could trade airline miles for coffee points, supermarket rewards

-: 05:03

for hotel stays, anything.

-: 05:06

It's like turning your loyalty into actual currency.

-: 05:07

That's a game changer. Yeah.

-: 05:11

But even with all this like futuristic tech, Kayan keeps coming

-: 05:14

back to this idea of like the psychology of loyalty.

-: 05:17

And honestly, it's kind of a paradox, isn't it? Yeah.

-: 05:20

We have more choices than ever as consumers, but companies are

-: 05:22

getting better at predicting what we want.

-: 05:25

So where does actual loyalty fit into all of this?

-: 05:27

That's the million dollar question, isn't it?

-: 05:31

Kayan argues that in this age of instant gratification and endless

-: 05:34

options, brands need to do more than just offer discounts and freebies.

-: 05:38

They need to cultivate a sense of belonging and emotional connection.

-: 05:42

So it's less about buy 10, get one free and more about creating

-: 05:43

a shared identity or purpose.

-: 05:45

But how do you do that?

-: 05:48

Can a grocery store really create the same kind of loyalty as,

-: 05:49

say, a brand like Patagonia?

-: 05:53

It's a different approach for sure for a company like Patagonia.

-: 05:57

Their values are front and center, environmentalism, sustainability, adventure.

-: 06:01

Their customers are buying into that ethos as much as they're

-: 06:02

buying a jacket. Right.

-: 06:03

It's like voting with your wallet.

-: 06:05

But what about the more mundane stuff?

-: 06:08

How does my local supermarket create that kind of emotional connection?

-: 06:10

It's about the little things.

-: 06:14

Maybe they remember your usual order, offer personalized recommendations

-: 06:18

based on your past purchases or support local charities that align

-: 06:19

with your community's values.

-: 06:24

It's about going beyond the algorithm and recognizing you as an individual.

-: 06:27

So less mass marketing, more targeted flirting.

-: 06:29

I can get behind that, but let's be real.

-: 06:30

There's always a flip side.

-: 06:33

Where's the line between personalization and manipulation?

-: 06:35

Yeah, that's where it gets tricky.

-: 06:36

And this is something Kayam really digs into.

-: 06:41

He points out that there's a potential dark side to all this data-driven personalization.

-: 06:44

If companies aren't careful, it can easily slip into manipulation

-: 06:48

using our own psychology against us to drive sales and profits.

-: 06:51

Okay, now I'm getting flashbacks to that Black Mirror episode

-: 06:54

where they personalized ads based on your deepest fears.

-: 06:56

Yeah, it's a valid concern.

-: 06:59

Kayam argues that transparency is key.

-: 07:02

We need to know how our data is being used, who has access to

-: 07:04

it, and what the potential downsides are.

-: 07:07

And we need to be empowered to make informed choices about who

-: 07:08

we trust with that information.

-: 07:12

So it's not just about blindly signing up for every loyalty program

-: 07:14

that promises free stuff. Right.

-: 07:17

We need to be a little more discerning, a little more savvy about

-: 07:19

where we're putting our data and our trust. Exactly.

-: 07:23

And that brings us to one of the most fascinating parts of Kayam's

-: 07:25

series, the role of AI in all of this.

-: 07:29

We're talking about algorithms that can predict your needs better

-: 07:32

than your spouse, chatbots that offer personalized recommendations,

-: 07:37

and even AI-powered loyalty programs that learn and evolve over time.

-: 07:39

Okay, now that's both cool and terrifying.

-: 07:42

It's like having a personal shopper in my pocket, but that personal

-: 07:46

shopper also knows every single thing about me, from my favorite

-: 07:47

coffee to my deepest insecurities.

-: 07:49

And that's the challenge, isn't it?

-: 07:53

As AI gets more sophisticated, as it blurs the lines between personalization

-: 07:57

and manipulation, we need to be having these conversations about

-: 08:00

ethical boundaries, data privacy, and what it means to be a conscious

-: 08:03

consumer in a world increasingly shaped by algorithms.

-: 08:05

You've definitely given me a lot to think about.

-: 08:08

I'm looking at my coffee rewards app in a whole new light now.

-: 08:10

That's the point of a deep dive, right?

-: 08:13

To uncover those hidden layers, to challenge our assumptions,

-: 08:16

and to help us navigate this complex world with a little more

-: 08:17

awareness and intention.

-: 08:19

I'm ready for more. Yeah.

-: 08:20

Let's keep diving.

-: 08:25

Okay, so we've explored the evolution of loyalty, the whole data

-: 08:30

dilemma, and even the potential for AI to become our personal shopping site.

-: 08:31

Yeah, it's been a wild ride.

-: 08:34

Where does all of this lead us?

-: 08:37

What's the future of loyalty in a world where everybody wants

-: 08:39

our attention and our data?

-: 08:42

Yeah, that's a question Kayem really leaves us grappling with.

-: 08:46

He paints this picture of a world where loyalty programs are so

-: 08:50

sophisticated, so personalized, that it's hard to resist their allure.

-: 08:54

Imagine getting offers that are perfectly tailored to your needs,

-: 08:57

your desires, almost before you even realize you have them.

-: 09:00

It's like they're reading our minds, but in a good way.

-: 09:04

No more spammy emails for lawnmowers when you live in a tiny apartment. Exactly.

-: 09:06

But here's where it gets really interesting.

-: 09:10

Kayem argues that as these programs become more sophisticated,

-: 09:14

the real winners might not actually be the consumers, but the

-: 09:17

companies themselves, because they're the ones gathering the data,

-: 09:20

refining the algorithms, and ultimately controlling the playing field.

-: 09:24

So while we're happily racking up points and enjoying those personalized

-: 09:29

perks, the companies are amassing these massive data sets that

-: 09:32

give them even more power and influence.

-: 09:35

It's starting to feel like a bit of a Faustian bargain.

-: 09:36

Yeah, that's a great way to put it.

-: 09:39

And it raises a whole host of ethical questions, like if companies

-: 09:43

are using our data to predict our behavior, to nudge us towards

-: 09:46

certain choices, where does free will come into play?

-: 09:50

It's almost like we're being programmed, you know, subtly influenced

-: 09:52

by algorithms we don't fully understand. Yeah.

-: 09:54

It's a little unnerving, to be honest. It is.

-: 09:57

And Kayem doesn't offer easy answers, but he does challenge us

-: 10:00

to think critically about our relationship with these programs,

-: 10:04

to be aware of the potential downsides, and to demand more transparency

-: 10:06

from the companies we're entrusting with our data.

-: 10:07

So what's the takeaway here?

-: 10:12

Should we all just ditch our loyalty cards and live off the grid? Not necessarily.

-: 10:15

I mean, there are benefits to these programs, as we've discussed,

-: 10:18

but I think the key is to be more conscious, more intentional

-: 10:19

about how we engage with them.

-: 10:21

OK, so what does that look like in practice?

-: 10:25

It starts with awareness, you know, read the fine print, understand

-: 10:27

what data you're sharing and how it's being used.

-: 10:30

Don't just blindly click agree for the sake of convenience.

-: 10:35

OK, so step one, channel our inner lawyer and scrutinize those

-: 10:37

terms and conditions. What else? Be selective.

-: 10:40

You don't need to sign up for every program out there.

-: 10:43

Choose the ones that offer genuine value and align with your personal values.

-: 10:47

So if I'm, like, passionate about sustainable coffee, I might

-: 10:50

choose a program that supports fair trade practices and eco-friendly

-: 10:53

farming, even if it means fewer points or discounts. Exactly.

-: 10:56

And don't be afraid to voice your concerns.

-: 11:00

If you feel like a company is being manipulative or using your

-: 11:03

data in a way that feels unethical, speak up.

-: 11:06

So it's not just about passively accepting whatever offers come our way.

-: 11:10

It's about being active participants, shaping the loyalty landscape

-: 11:12

with our choices and our voices. Precisely.

-: 11:15

And this brings us to one of Kayyam's most thought-provoking points.

-: 11:19

He suggests that as loyalty programs become more pervasive, more

-: 11:22

ingrained in our lives, they have the potential to evolve into

-: 11:25

something entirely new. I'm intrigued.

-: 11:26

What does that look like?

-: 11:28

Flying cars powered by loyalty points?

-: 11:32

Maybe not flying cars, but something equally transformative.

-: 11:36

Kayyam envisions a future where loyalty isn't just about transactional

-: 11:40

rewards, but about building genuine connections, fostering communities,

-: 11:42

and even driving social change.

-: 11:44

So it's not just about getting a free coffee.

-: 11:47

It's about using our collective loyalty to support causes we believe

-: 11:50

in to make a positive impact on the world. Exactly.

-: 11:54

Imagine a loyalty program that rewards you for volunteering your

-: 11:57

time donating to charity or reducing your carbon footprint.

-: 12:01

It's a radical idea, but it's not outside the realm of possibility.

-: 12:02

That's a future I can get behind.

-: 12:06

It's almost like turning loyalty into a force for good, a way

-: 12:08

to create a better world one point at a time.

-: 12:10

And that's ultimately the message Kayyam leaves us with.

-: 12:14

Loyalty at its core is about connection, about finding alignment

-: 12:17

between our values and the brands we choose to support.

-: 12:20

And as technology continues to evolve, we have an opportunity

-: 12:24

to shape the future of loyalty, to create a system that benefits

-: 12:27

both consumers and companies while also making a positive impact

-: 12:29

on society as a whole. Wow.

-: 12:32

That's a powerful vision and it's definitely made me rethink my

-: 12:34

whole relationship with loyalty programs.

-: 12:36

I'm not just a passive consumer anymore.

-: 12:39

I'm like a co-creator, an agent of change.

-: 12:42

It's a lot of responsibility, but it's also pretty exciting. It is.

-: 12:45

And if you want to explore these ideas further, I highly recommend

-: 12:48

checking out Kayyam's A Closer Look series on token wisdom.

-: 12:51

It's a deep dive worth taking. Absolutely.

-: 12:52

We'll include a link in the show notes.

-: 12:56

And to our listeners out there, thanks for joining us on this

-: 12:57

journey into the world of loyalty.

-: 13:00

It's a complex landscape, but hopefully we've given you some food

-: 13:04

for thought, some tools to navigate it with a little more awareness and intention.

-: 13:08

Until next time, keep those loyalty cards close, but keep your

-: 13:09

critical thinking even closer.